Living In Old Brookville, NY: A Comprehensive Guide

Old Brookville, New York, is a charming village located on the North Shore of Long Island. Known for its large, estate-like properties, excellent schools, and proximity to New York City, Old Brookville offers a luxurious and tranquil lifestyle. If you're considering a move to this prestigious village, this comprehensive guide will provide you with everything you need to know.

What is Old Brookville Known For?

Old Brookville is renowned for several key characteristics that make it a desirable place to live:

• Luxury Real Estate: The village boasts sprawling estates and impressive homes, many with extensive acreage and upscale amenities. This is a primary draw for those seeking privacy and a high-end living experience.
• Top-Rated Schools: Old Brookville is part of the highly regarded Jericho Union Free School District, known for its academic excellence and college-bound students. Education is a significant factor for families choosing to settle here.
• Quiet and Secluded Environment: Despite its proximity to New York City, Old Brookville maintains a peaceful, residential atmosphere. The lack of commercial development contributes to its serene character.
• Proximity to New York City: Commuting to Manhattan is feasible, making Old Brookville an attractive option for professionals who work in the city but prefer a suburban lifestyle.

Is Old Brookville a Good Place to Live?

Determining if a place is "good" to live depends heavily on individual preferences and priorities. Old Brookville offers a very specific lifestyle that appeals to some but not to others. Here's a breakdown of the pros and cons: — Tornado Warning In San Juan County, Utah: Stay Safe

Pros:

• Excellent Schools: The Jericho school district consistently ranks among the top in New York State, making it a major draw for families with children.
• Low Crime Rate: Old Brookville is known for its safety and security, with a significantly lower crime rate than the national average.
• Large Properties and Privacy: Many homes sit on multiple acres, providing residents with ample space and seclusion.
• Close to Nature: The village is surrounded by natural beauty, with numerous parks, preserves, and waterfront areas nearby.
• Prestige and Exclusivity: Old Brookville is considered one of the most affluent communities on Long Island, offering a certain level of prestige.

Cons:

• High Cost of Living: The cost of housing, taxes, and general living expenses in Old Brookville is very high. This is a major barrier for many prospective residents.
• Limited Commercial Development: The lack of local shops and restaurants means residents often need to drive to neighboring towns for everyday errands and dining.
• Car Dependent: Public transportation options are limited, making a car essential for getting around.
• Homogeneous Community: Old Brookville is a predominantly residential area, which may lack the diversity and vibrancy of more urban settings.
• Property Taxes: Property taxes in Old Brookville are substantial, reflecting the high property values and excellent school system.

What to Know About Moving to Old Brookville

If Old Brookville sounds like the right fit for you, here are some key considerations before making the move:

Real Estate in Old Brookville

• Types of Homes: Expect to find primarily large, single-family homes and estates. Many properties feature custom-built houses with luxurious amenities.
• Property Sizes: Lot sizes are typically generous, ranging from one acre to several acres or more. This provides ample space and privacy.
• Home Prices: Real estate in Old Brookville is among the most expensive in Long Island. Expect to pay a premium for the location, property size, and school district.
• Market Trends: Consult with a local real estate agent to understand current market conditions and pricing trends in Old Brookville.

Schools in Old Brookville

As mentioned, Old Brookville is part of the Jericho Union Free School District. This district is highly regarded for its academic performance and college placement rates.

• Jericho High School: Consistently ranked among the top high schools in New York State and the nation.
• Jericho Middle School: A strong middle school that prepares students for the rigors of high school.
• Elementary Schools: The district's elementary schools (Cantiague Elementary, Jackson Elementary, and Seaman Elementary) provide a solid foundation for young learners.
• Private Schools: There are also several private school options in the surrounding areas, offering alternative educational approaches.

Things to Do in and Around Old Brookville

While Old Brookville is primarily residential, there are still plenty of opportunities for recreation and entertainment nearby.

• Parks and Preserves:
  • Planting Fields Arboretum State Historic Park: A beautiful arboretum and state park with gardens, greenhouses, and historic buildings.
  • Muttontown Preserve: A large nature preserve with hiking trails and diverse wildlife.
• Beaches:
  • Long Island Sound Beaches: Several beaches along the Long Island Sound are within a short drive.
• Golf Courses:
  • Meadow Brook Club: A prestigious private golf club in Old Brookville.
  • Several other golf courses: Available in neighboring towns.
• Shopping and Dining:
  • The Village of Jericho: Offers a variety of shops and restaurants.
  • The Americana Manhasset: A high-end outdoor shopping mall located nearby.

Commuting from Old Brookville

• To New York City: The Long Island Rail Road (LIRR) provides train service to Penn Station in Manhattan from nearby stations like Syosset and Hicksville. The commute time is typically around 45-60 minutes.
• By Car: The Long Island Expressway (I-495) provides access to New York City and other parts of Long Island. However, traffic can be heavy during peak hours.
• Local Transportation: Public transportation within Old Brookville is limited, making a car essential.

Old Brookville FAQs

What is the population of Old Brookville?

The population of Old Brookville is relatively small, contributing to its quiet and exclusive atmosphere. As of the most recent estimates, the population is around 2,200 residents. This low population density is a key factor in the village's appeal for those seeking privacy and a close-knit community feel.

What is the average home price in Old Brookville?

The average home price in Old Brookville is significantly higher than the national average, reflecting the luxury real estate market and desirable location. Prices can vary widely depending on the size, condition, and location of the property, but the median home price typically falls between $2 million and $5 million or even higher for estate properties.

What are the property taxes like in Old Brookville?

Property taxes in Old Brookville are high due to the high property values and the excellent school system. Residents should factor in these costs when considering a move to the village. Property taxes can range from tens of thousands of dollars annually, depending on the assessed value of the property.

Is Old Brookville a safe place to live?

Old Brookville is considered a very safe place to live. The crime rate is significantly lower than both the national and state averages. The village's affluent and residential nature contributes to its low crime rates, making it an attractive option for families and individuals concerned about safety. — Mays Landing, NJ Weather Forecast & Updates

How far is Old Brookville from New York City?

Old Brookville is conveniently located within commuting distance of New York City. The distance to Midtown Manhattan is approximately 25 to 30 miles, depending on the specific route and traffic conditions. Commute times by car can range from 45 minutes to over an hour during peak hours.

What school district is Old Brookville in?

Old Brookville is part of the highly acclaimed Jericho Union Free School District. This school district is known for its academic excellence, consistently ranking among the top districts in New York State. The district includes several elementary schools, a middle school, and Jericho High School, all of which are highly regarded. — My Art Journey A Chronological Showcase Of Works From April To July 2025

Are there any private schools near Old Brookville?

Yes, there are several private school options in the vicinity of Old Brookville. These schools offer a range of educational philosophies and programs, providing alternatives to the public school system. Some notable private schools in the area include Friends Academy, Green Vale School, and Portledge School.

Conclusion

Old Brookville, NY, offers a unique blend of luxury, tranquility, and convenience. Its beautiful estates, top-rated schools, and proximity to New York City make it an attractive option for those seeking an upscale suburban lifestyle. However, the high cost of living and limited commercial development are important factors to consider. If you value privacy, excellent education, and a peaceful environment, Old Brookville may be the perfect place to call home. Contact a local real estate agent today to explore the available properties and learn more about this prestigious village.